A Rose for the Crown – by Anne Easter Smith – independent book review – Historical Fiction (England)

This is the sixth novel I have read from Anne Easter Smith – she is one of my favorite historical fiction writers. Her books focus on some of the more interesting historical figures involved in England’s “Wars of the Roses” saga. (i.e. King Richard III, Cecily Neville, Margaret of Burgundy, etc.) I gave this one four stars on Goodreads.

This time she tackles Katherine Haute, believed by some to be the mistress of King Richard III and mother to at least one of his illegitimate children. Historically, Richard is known to have either two or three illegitimate children. And Katherine is one women who received a regular payment from Richard. But beyond that — the author was free to make up a quite believable narrative where Katherine is not only the mother of Richard’s three bastards, but also the great romantic love of his life.

In keeping with my own preferences for historical fiction, this book is not filled with endless details of battle scenes. Instead the Wars of the Roses remain the backdrop — with historical events referenced in conversation, rather than unfolding in real time. Instead, at the novel’s center is Katherine’s life — her humble origins, the lucky breaks that lead to social advancement, her first encounter with a teenage Richard, and generally, life as a women living in the 1400s. Smith explores the limitations in power women suffered at this time, the ways in which they were bartered to seal alliances and expand holdings, and the sometimes difficult decisions they were forced to make because they had so little autonomy.

King Richard III
(To me, a good guy)
Image from Wikipedia

Still, these women are capable of fierce passion and deep friendship. They love and lose children. And help heal and care for each other and the men around them. In short, their relationships feel both true to their era AND to our own. In fact, that may be my favorite part of this novel — putting the lives of women, from all social strata, front and center while men, their politics, and war are secondary.

This is Smith’s earliest novel. And there were a few moments when I felt it drifted into cheap romance novel territory. As one example — consider Katherine’s first sexual encounter with Richard. He’s a 15-year-old virgin, she’s an inexperienced 18-year-old. But, surprise surprise — they both experience complete satisfaction. Hardly likely the first time with a teenage boy, wouldn’t you say?

Nevertheless, it was an engaging read that left me feeling more knowledgeable about the lives of medieval women and admiring a lovable central character who showed about as much spunk as was possible for the times.

One more winning aspect worth mentioning. Despite the stories of William Shakespeare, Smith also believes Richard III was a good guy who did NOT kill the Princes in the Tower. And since that is my own position, seeing Richard as a hero made the book that much more enjoyable.

Author Anne Easter Smith Photo from her Website

More about the author.

For those who might be interested, here’s a link to a Timeline of Greatest Hits from the Wars of the Roses.

You may be interested in my reviews of other books by Smith:

This Son of York

Queen by Right

Daughter of York